Pope Leo Keeps Traditionis Custodes — and Only 29% Believe

November 17, 2026 • 00:44:25
Pope Leo Keeps Traditionis Custodes — and Only 29% Believe
Crisis Point
Pope Leo Keeps Traditionis Custodes — and Only 29% Believe

Nov 17 2026 | 00:44:25

/

Hosted By

Eric Sammons

Show Notes

Pope Leo on Traditionis Custodes: “we will continue to follow that." New study: only 28.8% of U.S. Catholics believe in the Real Presence. Find out why these two stories are not unrelated.
View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Foreign. [00:00:11] Welcome to Crisis Point. I'm Eric Sammons, your host, editor, chief of Crisis magazine. Before we get started, I just want to encourage everybody to subscribe to the channel, click the like button. I've had people tell me they don't like me saying smash the like button. I think it's too, I don't know, vulgar or childish, whatever, but do whatever you do to the like button, but make sure it's clicked. Also, I just want to thank you to all the people who donated during our little mini fundraising campaign we had the last couple weeks. We reached our goal. We wanted to raise $15,000. In two weeks, we raised about 16 and a half thousand. So I really do appreciate that and I just thank you because we couldn't do anything we do without the donors. So thank you for everybody who donates to Crisis magazine. If you want to become a donor, just go to crisismagazine.com click on the donor button in the upper right, I think it is, and donate. And also subscribe to our newsletter. Just go crisis magazine.com, fill in your address, email address on the subscribe section on the. On the homepage, and you'll get our email once a day. We won't. We promise not to spam you. Okay. And Also today, actually November 17th, is the official launch date, the official release date of my book, the Catholic Guide to Artificial Intelligence. If you haven't gotten a copy, why haven't you? It's out now. If you go to Amazon, they will ship it to you. If you go to Sophia Institute Press, they will ship it to you. If you go to ericsammons.com I will ship it to you personally. I will literally, personally. It will be me who puts the book into the package and sends it to you after I sign it. Only we can get signed copies. If you go to ericsammons.com okay, I'm not going to talk about any of that stuff today, though. I want to talk about what I think is the big news in the Catholic world. There's a couple stories I want to bring together. The biggest, though, is that unfortunately, we still have airplane interviews. I heard rumors they're going to get rid of papal airplane interviews, but clearly they didn't because we had an airplane interview, a press conference at least, with Pope Leo, and he was asked about tradition as custodes, which of course, is the. [00:02:11] I think it was mode appropriate. Yeah, I think that's what kind of document was from Pope Francis in 2021, I believe it was, which. Which greatly restricted the celebration of traditional Latin Mass. And so he was asked whether he would make Traditionus Custodis more flexible. That was the question. [00:02:28] And he said tradition. And these are like some working translations that are recent, but it said, traditionus Custodis is the decision of Pope Francis, and we will not. And I'm sorry, and we will continue to follow that. [00:02:42] So he said, tradius Custodis is the decision of Pope Francis, and we will continue to follow that. He also said Traditionus Custodis includes possibilities of dispensation or of allowing the Trinity Mass to be celebrated. [00:02:57] So he immediately says, yes, it's still the law of the land, but there are dispensations available, which, remember, the point of Tristinius Custosis was eventually to be there were no exceptions to the rule. But he's saying there are dispensations. [00:03:12] And he follows and says, and so again, for the unity of church, the vast majority of Catholics around the world, we celebrate the Rite of Vatican II of Paul vi, and we will continue to do that. And there is an avenue available for those who wish to apply for the dispensation. So he mentioned dispensation again. So some of this he's just kind of saying, I'm not changing anything Tradition, I'm not rescinding it. [00:03:35] He's saying the vast majority of Catholics celebrate the, who go to Mass, celebrate the, the Mass of Vatican ii, whatever they call it this week, the Mass of Paul vi. And that's true. There's no, nobody argues that point. [00:03:49] And he mentions, though, there is distance, there is an avenue for dispensation. Now, we all know in practice that the avenue for dispensations is very jagged. It's very jagged. Some people, some bishops allow the traditional Mass to be celebrated pretty openly. Other, other bishops do not have restricted it much more severely and all kind of say Traditionos Custodis allows this. So the reality on, on the, on the ground is that it depends on where you live, really. It depends on where you live on whether or not the traditional Latin Mass is celebrated more freely or not. [00:04:28] And so, but this is what he said. And so of course, we know the context of this is that we're all, okay, let's just. I want to put my cards on the table. I'm disappointed. Of course I'm disappointed. I attended traditional at Mass. I think the traditional at Mass is very important. I think it's important that is celebrated as widely as possible in the Catholic Church. I think it's a key component of the reform, restoration of the Catholic Church. In the world today. [00:04:57] And so I'm disappointed by anything other than a complete reversal of judicious custodes. [00:05:03] That being said, I'm not. I'm not surprised, though. I'm not like, shocked. I mean, if he was going to change it, he was. He would have changed it by now. If he would have rescinded, he would have rescinded it by now, I think. A couple comments I saw online was Damien Thompson said it's not ideal, but could have been so much worse. He's allowing himself and bishops a lot of freedom for maneuvering. He affirms custodians and immediately talks about dispensations from it. He does this twice. And that's a good point that Damian makes. And I think he's right that we, it could have been a lot worse. We could have been had a true ideologue who was like, I'm going to implement the. The final solution to tradition, which is the abolition of the traditional Latin Mass. Joseph Shaw, Latin Mass Society friend of the podcast. He's great. He said he's ruling out repeal of Terticus Custodis for the moment, but the range of possibilities that remain is still enormous. To the point that this doesn't tell us very much at all. [00:05:58] Says it leaves everything exactly as it was, is going to continue for now. And I think that's true. [00:06:03] It doesn't really tell. [00:06:05] It really isn't that. [00:06:07] I know it's a big news story, but in another sense it's not because he's not doing anything different. He's just saying, this is what I've been doing, this will continue doing. Like I said, I'm disappointed. I don't want to act like I'm not disappointed, but I think it's. It's not something to just shock any of us. I know some people are saying it's just proof he's Francis 2.0. No, it's actually proof he's not Francis 2.0, because Francis 2.0 did not talk about dispensation so much. Literally. [00:06:32] I think that, that Pope Leo has talked about dispensations from Triticinus Custodis two more times than Pope Leo ever. Pope Francis ever did. Because he's talked about it twice now. He mentioned it twice in that. In that answer. That's probably two more times than Francis ever talked about. Because remember, if you. I remember, I'm old enough to remember five years ago when it was implemented, that it was clear the purpose of it was this is the first step towards the eventual complete Abolition, complete removal of the traditional Latin Mass from the life of the Church. That was the purpose of it. And that's not what, that's not what Leo's saying. [00:07:09] Obviously I think he should, he should rescind tc but you know, that's. It is what it is. Now what I want to do though is I want to tie this news to some other news that came out, another headline that came out, because I think they're directly related and I don't see a lot of people talking about this, but I think this is where we dig a little deeper. I'm not just somebody who's just like, let's just scream about the headlines, get mad at Pope Leo and talk about how awful things are. I want to dig a little deeper and say, okay, what's the impact of this? And how is this really, why does this matter? Why does this, does this matter for Catholics? [00:07:41] And the story I want to do, I want to mention is it was just noticed. It was actually, I think it was published back in September, but it was just kind of went viral or when was noticed. In the past week there was a study done in the Sociological Inquiry that was a survey of 5400 US adults. [00:08:01] In September of 2025 and 1049 self identified Catholics were asked the question, do you believe that when the priest consecrates the host during Mass that the bread and wine are transformed, actually becoming the body and blood of Christ? Or do you believe the bread and wine are symbols of this body, of his body and blood? Or are you not sure what happens? So these are people who are self identified Catholics. Now note, of course it does. We'll get to this in a moment. They go a little deeper. But this could be somebody who never goes to Mass, somebody who goes to daily Mass, but they say I am Catholic. So they might be a baptized Catholic and say, and they might not self identify anymore. They're not included. But these are people who self identify as Catholic. So on some level they're attached to the Catholic Church. [00:08:45] And so they're given three options. Do you believe that the host, the bread and wine are actually transferred into the body and blood of Christ? [00:08:54] Do you believe the bread or do you believe they're bruised symbols of his body and blood? Or are you not sure what happens? I'm hoping, I'm hoping 100% of my audience knows the correct answer is because there is a correct answer. It's not an opinion. Something actually does happen. Obviously it's the first option. It literally becomes the body and Blood of Christ. [00:09:14] Now this question is very important because, and we're going to get this in a moment, but I want to remind people, back in 2019, there was a study done, a survey done like this, and it showed about 31% of Catholics, self identified Catholics, said they believe it really is the buying blood of Christ. So what is the result of this survey done in 2025? 28.8%, 28.8% believe that the bread and wine truly become the buying blood of Christ. 58.8% say they're just symbols and 12.4% say I'm not sure what happens. [00:09:53] So again, only 20, less than 30% really, probably with rounding, you know, with rounding errors, things like that, statistical rounding, whatever, it's about the same. In other words, it has not changed since 2025. The, the number of people who say the percent of self identified Catholics who say it is the buying blood of Christ. And also there was a Gallup poll in 1992 that asked a similar question and it also said 30%. [00:10:23] So let me put that up there here on the screen for you. Those who are watching. [00:10:29] In 1992, 30% of Catholics said they believe it's the buying blood of Christ. In 2019, in the Pew study, 31% said in 2025, 28.8% said they believe it's the buying blood of Christ. In other words, in three decades there's been absolutely no change in the percentage of Catholics who this is us Catholics who believe it's actually the body and blood of Jesus Christ. [00:10:54] So that means 70% of Catholics reject the Church's dogmatic teaching on transubstantiation. And if you know from the little chart, if you're watching, you can see the little chart here. What, what did I, what I put in there? What happened between 2019 and, and 2025? There's a little thing called the national eucharistic revival. [00:11:13] From 2022 to 2025, it was a three year program that basically was the purpose of it. Literally this was, this was by the bishops called this out, this revival because of the results of that 2019 survey. [00:11:32] The bishop saw, wow, 70% of Catholics in America reject the real presence. We gotta do something about it. So what did they do? They decided to spend tens of millions of dollars and have a three year national Eucharistic Revival. What are the preliminary results? What are the results so far? This was taken to basically two months after it ended. [00:11:52] Nothing, not any, just zero, zero result. [00:11:59] The needle did not move. The needle did not move at all. It just remained exactly where it was before on, on the percent of belief. And we're going to get in why I think that is here in a minute. I also just want to show a couple other numbers from this survey. [00:12:14] If you go to Mass, like 28 of all Catholics say they believe in real presence. If you go to Mass Weekly, about 60% say they believe in world presidents. If you go more than weekly, just under 70%, obviously that's way better. But I also think that's pathetic. [00:12:33] You're telling me people, 30% of Catholics who go to Mass more than once a week don't even believe in the royal presence? [00:12:40] I, I, I, I'm going to give a little bit for errors and not understanding the question, some errors and just ignorance, not understanding really what's meant. But I mean that is, that is damning. That statistic is damning. [00:12:52] 30% of Catholics who attend Mass more than once a week don't even believe in the real presence. That's crazy. [00:12:59] And another one, that just another thing from this study. [00:13:02] If faith is very important to you, these are the Catholics who said the faith is very important. [00:13:07] About 40% believe in the world presence. If they say faith is more important than anything else, 75% believe in the real presence. [00:13:16] And if they attend weekly Mass and they put faith above all, and they were at Mass last weekend, about 88%, I still think that's bad. I still think 88%. Obviously it's better than 28%, but it's still not that great that 12% of people who do all those things. Can you imagine that you attend Mass weekly, you're at Mass last week, you believe. Faith is the most important thing to you and yet you still don't believe in the world presence. 10%, 12% of people fall in that category. [00:13:43] So what we're seeing though very clearly is that the, the, the Catholics do not believe. Let me put up one more time. Only less than 30% of Catholics, self identified Catholics in America believe in the real presence. Less than 3%. And that number again, I'll put this chart up too, has not changed in 30 years. In more than 30 years is not changed yet. We had this humongous eucharistic revival. And so why is it that the Eucharistic revival, at least initially has had no impact? [00:14:15] I want to be fair here and say it's not like it would happen overnight. At the same time, I want to say it was a three year revival. So it's not also like it was Just this survey taken two months after it ended isn't like it was only a one time event. It was a one day event. It was like a three year event. And yet it didn't even move the needle on how, on how Catholics believe in the real presence. [00:14:41] And I, you know, let's remind, remember what this Eucharistic revival is. It was launched in 2022 on the Feast of Corpus Christi. It was a three year program. There was a diocesan year, a parish year, then the 10th National Eucharistic Congress in Indianapolis, which I went to. It was the first in 83 years. [00:15:00] There were 50 to 60,000 participants. [00:15:03] Estimated it came in, like I said, over $14 million. [00:15:09] Cost, I think even more than that. [00:15:11] And what did it emphasize? Catechesis and small group studies, adoration, nationwide processions, a stadium congress of talks, revival nights, benediction, then a walk with one year of mission. [00:15:24] And so the question is, why didn't it have really any impact? Why is it that we had this huge national Eucharistic revival over three years at least so far we see zero impact. I mean, zero impact. It's not even like it budgeted a little bit. [00:15:42] I think it goes back to the top news story I said in this podcast, and that's Traditionius custodes. But more broadly, the attitude of the hierarchy and many priests towards the liturgy, essentially we have to remember over and over again, lexerende lex credendae. Lexerende lex credende. Lexerende lex credendae. What do I mean by that? What we pray is what we believe. [00:16:12] And I think essentially what the Eucharistic revival did not touch, it did not touch. [00:16:18] It was like the third rail of Catholic, of the Catholic world, which is how the liturgy is celebrated. [00:16:26] Now I will say in their, in their, the Congress did, the Eucharist of Congress did advertise reverent liturgies. It had a Latin Mass there, traditional Mass there, celebrated by Archbishop Cordelian, which I attended. I think it had an Eastern rite or two liturgy as well. [00:16:42] I think the liturgies at the Eucharist of Congress, I don't, I don't know because I wasn't there for any of them other than the Latin Mass one, I'm sure were done better than most parishes. [00:16:52] But ultimately this whole program, the diocesan year, the parish year, all this stuff, none of it really, it was, it was just more talk. It was more talk, more programs, and it didn't emphasize, it didn't talk at all about how liturgy celebrate. Because here's the reality. [00:17:10] You can talk until you're blue in the face about what the church believes, about what the, about what the, the real presence means. You can do catechesis up the wazoo about it. [00:17:23] But ultimately, if every week when you go to Mass, you see a liturgy irreverently celebrated that is going to inform your beliefs more than all that teaching and catechesis, why repeat it for me in the audience? Lex serende, Lex Credenda. [00:17:43] If you have a priest, I mean I, I think we've all probably been the masses like this. You have a priest who like during the consecration he throws up the host with one hand, kind of says, you know, and then puts it back down, you know, and, and treats it very irreverently that more people going to think if you see everybody, I mean, I've talked about this a couple months ago and people got all mad at me. Some people at least got mad at me going to a local parish, Novus Ordo, because of various things going on. My family, everybody dressed there like they're going off to the golf course or to the football game. Almost everybody receives in the hand. The music was horrible. The, the architecture was terrible. The, the, everything about it just screamed we don't care what's going on here. We take this seriously. We don't really believe all that impacts you far more than some eucharistic congress in Indianapolis, Indiana or some program that your diocese is sponsoring to give you more teaching, more teaching, more teaching, blah blah, blah, blah, blah, just talking, talking, talking. [00:18:44] And yet when you go to mass, you have terrible music. You have, you know, you, you have terrible architecture. You have a priest who, who doesn't seem to take seriously what, what's actually happening here. You have legions of eucharistic ministers, all the blue haired ladies walking up to, to distribute it like it's a PEZ dispenser. The body, blood, soul and divinity of our Lord. People receiving on the hand. I mean I remember, I mean I remember like during COVID I, I, I turned on a master. My old parish, I'm not going to name what it was old Novasor because I just kind of want to see how, what their roles were. They were doing and they were doing this thing where everybody had receiving the hand and the priest would literally wash it, you know, wash his hands after each time he gave out the host. Remember at one point one of the people dropped the host and all I do is just pick it up and walk off. Nothing else that screams a message that we don't really believe this is the buying blood crisis. This is just a symbol at most. [00:19:43] And so this is what people experience, though, on a weekly basis, if not more. You can start to understand why even daily mass goers, even 30 daily mask goers, or at least more than weekly massacres, don't believe in the real presence, if that's what they're experiencing each week. I don't care how many podcasts they listen to, I don't care how many sermons they might hear about the real presence. I don't care how many classes they go to or how many diocesan programs they go to. [00:20:08] That's what they're really, that's really what's going to come in for them. That's what they're going to believe. [00:20:14] And so when you, when we see this, when we have this, this experience, this is what happens. And I think this is where I, I, I've, I've talked about this before. [00:20:25] I feel like over the, something happened. I mean, I know we want to blame Vatican II for everything. I'm not here to blame Vatican ii, actually. [00:20:33] I think fundamentally, one thing that I think was probably the worst thing to happen in the church is we completely changed how we teach. [00:20:45] The Church's pedagogy radically altered at some point. [00:20:51] I want to say the 1960s, 1970s, by the 1970s, it surely was in place. I don't know, maybe it started in the 1950s and before. I don't know. [00:20:59] What do I mean by that? [00:21:01] The, the Church's pedagogy, if you look at traditionally throughout history, it's always been an immersive experience. [00:21:09] The faith is not transmitted as much as it's absorbed. [00:21:15] Basically, what happens is you live and breathe the faith. As a Catholic growing up, you live and breathe it. It's in the very air you breathe. You have pictures of the saints around you. [00:21:29] You have beautiful Gregorian chant you're listening to. You have this wonderful music. You have a reverend liturgy. You have the priest who's facing the same direction as the people leading him and leading them in worship. You have altar rails, you have people kneeling for communion. You have people receiving on the tongue. You have all these things and there's more than that. That's just kind of the, the surface of it. [00:21:50] And you live and breathe this. [00:21:52] You can't help but believe that it's the body and blood of Christ, because otherwise you reject it. You would reject it all. You definitely wouldn't self identify as Catholic anymore. [00:22:04] It's the only, it's the only logical conclusion after you you, you, you, you experience all this. [00:22:12] That was the way the church. Yes, there were catechism classes, yes, there were things that, that people, you know, that you were taught the faith, but that was almost more like a, an add on to the real teaching of the faith, was just simply living it out, looking, especially in the liturgy. That was the church's pedagogy. But at some point, the church embraced the idea that our pedagogy is just going to be a bunch of yapping, a bunch of, you know, jibber jabbering and talking about the faith. You see this in the Eucharistic revival. You see this in everything the church organizes anymore. It's all focused on telling people things. [00:22:53] Of course, I do believe we have to proclaim the gospel. We have to talk. I'm, I'm yapping right now in this podcast. [00:22:59] So I don't think we don't, it's not that we don't ever talk. [00:23:02] It's. That's not the primary means in which the faith is transmitted though. [00:23:06] When I, you know, let's break it down to like in a family, when I'm raising my kids and I'm teaching them the faith. [00:23:14] Yes, we sit down with them and we go through the Baltimore Catechism with them. We make sure they understand the teachings of faith. They memorize certain aspects of the faith, and they learn the faith in that way in cl. In, in our homeschooling classes. Absolutely. They also go to catechism classes at our parish. All those things are important. [00:23:32] But my wife and I both would say that is just the tip of the iceberg for how they learn the faith. It's the living it out that they really learn it. The living it out and experiencing the liturgy. That's how they really understand the faith and live it out. By the way, quick shout out. My son Peter was on the Avoiding Babylon podcast with Anthony Abate and Rob. And I'm not sure if I remember Rob's last name. I don't know if he makes it public. But anyway, he was on last week. He talked about growing up Catholic in the Sammons family. If you want to check it out, just the Avoiding Babylon podcast. I recommend it. I was. Yes, I'm a proud papa. I will be the first to admit it. And I want to thank Anthony and Rob for, for having Peter on. And Majoram. Majorium, I think you pronounce. It was another young man who, who seemed like a wonderful young man who was also on the podcast. So that's just a quick aside check out that podcast. Okay, but the point here is, is that the churches pedagogy radically changed. And so when the Eucharistic revival, when, when the Eucharistic revival was decided, let's do this national Eucharistic revival, what was it? How was it front loaded? It was front loaded with teaching, with talking, with presenting the faith, things like that. [00:24:42] But there was no discussion of, let's really be serious about how the liturgy itself is celebrated in parishes. If you remember, with tradition's custodes, I think the letter that Pope Francis included with it, it had a throwaway line about the Novus Ordo needs to be reverently celebrated as well. [00:25:02] We all know it's a throwaway line because they've literally never done anything to enforce that ever, ever, ever. [00:25:08] In 60 years, however long it's been since the, the 50 plus years it's been since Nosaurus started, there's never been an enforcement of any real meaning about the reverence of the Novus Ordo ever. [00:25:24] And so we know it was, it was just a thing, a sop to throw in there to make it look like you cared about that. But nobody does care. They don't care because they did. They wouldn't enforce it. Even the best bishops, God love them. And I'm not here to Bishop Bash. I think there's some good bishops out there who are trying their best even they don't go down this path because they know it's, they don't have the political capital to survive it. [00:25:48] If some bishop decided, okay, I'm going to make sure every single parish in my diocese has irreverently celebrated liturgy. Note, I didn't say a Traditional Latin Mass, I just said a reverently celebrated liturgy, I. E. The Novus Ordo. And we can talk all we want about, we can debate about the, the, you know, the unicorn Novus Ordos and versus The Traditional Latin Mass, all that stuff. I'm just simply, I'm not even asking for Traditional Latin Mass everywhere. I'm just simply saying if the Novus Ordo itself were traditionally celebrated, reverently celebrated with things like ad orientum, alter rails, communion in the, in the tongue, all things that Vatican II didn't have anything to say about. [00:26:28] If all those things were included and that was the Mass every single person experienced, I guarantee that number would be way higher. I guarantee even if you didn't have a traditional Mass, you had to know, sort of. But every single, no sort of Ordo in America was celebrated like the, the so called unicorn Masses I guarantee that number would be a lot higher. I would put it at 60, 70% or more. [00:26:53] Now, to be clear, I personally think we need to go traditional Mass everywhere. I think it needs to be the one right, Roman, right. I think that's the path forward. I think that's the ultimate destination we're going to go, go back to. I really do believe that. It might not be in my lifetime, but it's going to happen. Not going to happen overnight, but it's going to happen one day. But let's just even, we're just talking now, temporary, you know, practically right now, I guarantee that would happen. And so if the bishops were serious when they saw that Pew study in 2019 that said only 30% of Catholics believe in real presence, if they were like, I really, really, really want to up this and make it higher, they wouldn't even had to spend a dime. They spent 14 million or whatever it was. They don't even have to spend a dime. All they'd have to do is enforce certain rules about how the Novus Ordo Mass is celebrated. And I guarantee that number would go up a lot. [00:27:48] I don't think it'd be 100%. I don't think it'd be where we'd want it to be, which is 100%, but it'd be a lot higher. [00:27:54] It'd have a dramatically more, greater impact than, than what we, what we actually had, which was zero impact. Why don't they do that? That's the question. I mean, the reality is, I really think it's just ideological. It's, it's the, it's the demographics of our bishops, their age and kind of what they were invested in. [00:28:15] And also, I think it's just politically, it's still too difficult. You know who, number one, would be against that doing something like that? The boomers. The boomers. And yeah, go ahead, let's have the obligatory comment from some boomers saying they're not all, like, they're not all like that. I know you're not all like that, but you know what I mean? It's the boomers. [00:28:33] If you, if, if a parish all of a sudden implemented a traditionally celebrated, excuse me, Novus Ordo Mass, even if they did over like, let's say a six month time period with the priest giving catechesis of why they're doing it and what they should expect and implementing it over time, let's say a six month time frame, they would still freak out. They would complain to the bishop, they'd withhold their Their, their, their donations, and they would just go crazy. And the bishops aren't going to stand up to that. They're not going to stand up to that. We all know that. I mean, a lot of them would agree with the boomers, but even the ones who don't agree with the boomers, they, they just, it's just not worth it to them. It's just not worth it them to fight that. That battle is not worth fighting. I mean, it should be worth fighting, but it's not. [00:29:21] And so the reality is we just see that we're not going to change that number on the path we're on. And the fact that Pope Leo decided to not rescind Traditionus Custodes and kind of keep things the way they are, I think just shows we're. That number is not changing anytime soon. Because if you're not going to resent tradition's custodes, you're not going to be serious about the Novus Ordo being reverently celebrated. Now, you could argue there could be a world in which the Pope and the bishops decide, okay, we're not going to rescind Tristinius Cassos, we're not going to allow the Traditional Latin Mass in very many places. We're going to restrict it, but we really are going to implement a lot of rules about the Novus or how it's celebrated and make sure it's reverent. There is a world, I guess, in which that could happen. It's a fantasy world, but I guess it could exist in some multiverse. [00:30:14] I mean, the reality is we've seen that after, you know, what actually happened, a lot of the kind of TLM aspects of the Novus Ordo were banned. [00:30:25] Like bishops started banning ad orientum at the Novus Ordo after Titusinus Custodes, they started banning altar rails, they started banning other reverent things, reverent aspects of the Novus Ordo. To them, it's all connected. Because the point isn't Novus Ordo versus Traditional Latin Mass. The point is, is it a modern, like, boomer liturgy or isn't it? [00:30:48] That's really what it is. You can't, you can't turn the traditional Mass into a boomer liturgy. So you just have to, you know, only the Novus Oral can be turned into a boomer liturgy. So that's why they have to get rid of the Traditional Latin Mass. But really, ultimately, it's not that they want a reverent liturgy. They want a boomer liturgy. A lot of people in A lot of people in high ranking in the church and just because that's what they grew up with, that's what they're used to, that's what they think is normal. They don't see. [00:31:13] They, I mean, I think some might see, but I think most of them don't see the connection between that and that. 28.8% of Catholics who reject, who accept the real presence, they don't see the connection there. But the connection should be clear as day to people who understand what the liturgy is, who understand what. Lex arende, lex credende. That's our, that's our line for the day. You get, you know, a prize if you say, if the first caller calls in, says it or whatever. They didn't back in the days on the radio. [00:31:41] Okay, so I think I've kind of beat that drum. I also do want to bring up, just real quick before I get to the live chat and people talking in it, one of the things that Pope Leo said about this is, it's, it's for unity. How I think I wrote it down up here. What did he say? Let me find that. His, his actual quote. What he said, he said for the unity of church. The vast majority of Catholics around the world, we celebrate the Rite of Acitu of Paul VI and continue to do so. And this was the argument of Pope Francis and a lot of bishops is we do this. So it's unity. Now, I've already kind of torn that apart years ago. I remember talking about this on some podcast. The reality is the church has never had one liturgy. [00:32:26] I mean, if you really want unity, you'd ban the Eastern rites, you'd ban the ordinariates. You know, you'd only have one Mass for every single person to be identical. That's never been the church's idea of unity. Now the reality is, within a single right, like the Roman right, I do think there should be unity, but it should be, of course, the traditional Latin Mass. But the idea that you're going to allow things like the Ordinariate and have no problem with that, and you're going to allow the no Source celebrate in a billion different ways. And we all know that the, the practice on the street is you go to one Mass, it's very different from going to another Mass down the street. How they celebrate radically different. Bishops might not know this very much by the way, because when they go, the, the parish will always celebrate the Mass according to how they think the bishop will like it. So there's that difference between Parishes isn't as noticeable to a bishop as it is to most of us, to regular laypeople. [00:33:17] But I just think there's. There's a problem with this idea of unity. What is it that brings about unity in Catholicism? Remember unity in the world, like political unity or social unity. [00:33:30] It's around some concept, some belief that everybody has. Like, for example, in America or in your town or wherever, or your family, whatever the case may be. [00:33:41] Well, in the church, it's unity around the deposit of faith. And what's one of the most core doctrines of the deposit of faith? [00:33:48] The real presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. [00:33:51] And if we're clearly, you know what Catholics are somewhat united on right now? A rejection of the real presence. If 70% reject the real presence, that's where the unity is. [00:34:04] Because if all we want is unity, you know what the easier path to it is? [00:34:09] Just have everybody reject the real presence. [00:34:12] I mean, you only go from 70 to. You only to go from 70 to 100 instead of from 30% to 100%. [00:34:18] So unity is never the ultimate goal. Our Lord himself talks about bringing a sword and dividing families and dividing peoples. [00:34:26] Unity is not. The goal is union with God, union with an acceptance of his deposit of faith, which that then, as a corollary, brings about unity between people. Our unity is not actually unity. I hate that word. The real word is communion. [00:34:43] When it comes to Catholics, the word is not unity, it's communion. That's how we're united. [00:34:48] And how are we united in a communion through Holy Communion. [00:34:53] And if it's just a symbol, well, to hell with it. [00:34:56] What's the point? [00:34:58] We're just a social group. If it's just a symbol, then we're just a social group, and it's a big waste of time. [00:35:05] It's a big waste of time. If it's just a symbol. No, it is the buying blood of Christ, which only 28.8% of us actually believe. [00:35:13] So unity is not what the focus should be. We should not be focused on unity. We should be focused on a shared belief in the Eucharist, which comes about through a celebration of the liturgy in a way that fosters that belief in the Eucharist in the real presence. [00:35:32] And so obviously, it's not going to happen anytime soon. We're not going to have a revival. A true revival tradition of Cassowis has to be rescinded for that to happen. Now, I am hopeful, excuse me, that the Pope's words about lots of. About dispensations, mentioning it twice will lead to more parishes, more asking for dispensations, for more bishops being granted dispensations, and for the Vatican not harassing bishops to stop the. The traditional Latin Mass. I'm hopeful that maybe that will happen. Maybe it will be. It won't be as good as before under Pope Benedict, but it won't be as bad as it has been over the past few years. Since tradition is custodes, that's what I'm hopeful for. We need. Obviously, we need to pray. And so ultimately, what's our word of the day or phrase a day? Lecturende lex credende. We will not have a bump in that number of who believes in the real presence until we really have a revival in how the liturgy itself is celebrated. Just period, end of story. There's no other way. [00:36:40] Okay, let's go through this live chat a little bit. I. Again, I don't have an assistant. I probably need to get one who will go through these for me and help me out with this. But until then, I will just do it myself. Going solo here. Let's do it live. Crusader says Pope Leo said he has no immediate plans to lift the restrictions on the tlm. I believe that answer is in deference to Francis. I think he'll be more liberal with dispensation requests if request if requested. So far that has not happened. But I'm hopeful you are right. I'm. I. I do believe it is possible you are right. And I think. I do think it's been clear. [00:37:12] Leo's made it clear he's not going to rescind anything Francis did. He's not going to do a outright rejection of anything Francis did, which I wish he did, but he's not going to. I do think he's changing some things. How Francis is doing, how Francis did things. And so my hope is that over time, Tristius Castus at least becomes a dead letter. [00:37:33] Okay. His language is very much akin to this is Adam. His language is very much akin to this is what Francis did. We should respect it, but we will still be granting dispensation. Seems like he's distanced himself from the document slowly, albeit. Yeah, I'm hopeful that that's exactly right. I'm hopeful that that's what the case is. [00:37:50] Thomas. Jess said leo should flip TC and do the exact opposite. Only allow TLMs and normally parishes alongside the current normative suppressive societies whose parishes foster crypto schismatic separatism. I don't know. I. Okay. There's a new book out by. Thanks, Tom. There's a new book out by Stephen Bullivant called Trads and I can't wait to get it and read it. But I heard an interview with him where he's talking about the reality is in America at least the majority of people who attend the traditional Mass, some also attend the Novus Ordo that they don't attend just exclusive traditional Mass that is a reserve for a very small number of people. Mostly people go the SSPX and you know, some people go like FSSP and places like that. I know people like that. [00:38:35] But I don't think there's this. I don't think there is a, a large number of what Tom says is the crypto schismatic separatism existing actually in most parishes that, that celebrate most societies obviously the size of 10th maybe, but not in like the, the FSSP or institute. But I do like his. Your suggestion, Tom, of, of maybe flipping. Flipping it. [00:39:00] I mean, honestly, at this point, I would just love to see some implementation of a reverent Novus Ordo and see what happens. Like they actually enforce it. I mean, I don't see that ever happening anytime soon. But we'll see. [00:39:13] Okay. The good fight Tony says Dallas Diocesan City report said would provide a catechetical Mass video including quote, liturgical actions and postures of the priest, ministers and lady. We'll see if any effective changes. Yeah, the question is, will it be a dead letter? Will it be a dead letter? Will they actually implement it in the reality? In reality, will priests actually be punished if they don't follow the rubrics properly? That's the real question. Because we all know if a priest decides to celebrate ad orientum, he is shot down quickly. Quickly. [00:39:50] But if he just throws up one hand to kind of say, hey, here's the host. If he, if he doesn't follow the text and does things irreverently, stuff like that, nothing will happen. Nothing will happen to him. So only when something actually happens to the priest who doesn't follow the rubrics, that's when I'll. I'll believe it. [00:40:06] Gracie says I find it funny he's unwilling to repeal what cruelty Francis unleashed. I mean, that's harsh, but it's true, Gracie. But Francis had no qualms about destroying what Benedict put in place. That brought much peace to the Church. That is the irony, Gracie. That is the irony. I'm glad you bring that up. [00:40:22] Benedict brought a lot of peace to the church. [00:40:25] Francis squashed it and just destroyed that peace. [00:40:30] And so, and he didn't care about Benedict's legacy in doing that. [00:40:35] Leo does seem to be a little bit overly concerned about Francis's legacy. The reality is Francis legacy, we know what it's going to be. It's going to be destruction and awfulness. [00:40:45] And so trying to keep his legacy, I just think is a misguided effort. [00:40:50] There might be some prudential political reasons for that. You know, he's got to get things done. A lot of bishops, like, still were, you know, like what Francis was doing. So he's not gonna. [00:40:59] Okay, here's something I want to bring up. I brought this up. My wife, I was talking about her, to her about this this morning. [00:41:05] The reality is this isn't very high on the list of priorities in the Vatican. The traditional Mass, we are not that important. It's not a hill to die on for. For the Pope. I think, and I think most popes would consider it like that. Most bishops considered that. It's just not a hill to die on. It's not worth the political capital to try to. To res. If he rescinded traditions. Custodians, by the way, I don't think this is right. I think you do it because it's the right thing to do and all that. I'm just simply saying the reality of what's happening is, I think that it's just a matter of, like, it's not really worth it. The, the political capital he would have to expend for that, I just think doesn't. Doesn't add up for him. [00:41:44] Crusader state isn't the real presence the fundamental difference between Catholicism and other Christian religions? If you don't believe, you are not a real Catholic. Yeah, that is true. I mean, Orthodox also believe in. In that it's truly the body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ. [00:41:57] They believe in the real presence in. In their own way. Other than that, though, no other Christians do believe that really is. They believe it is a symbol on some level. And so it is what makes us Catholics. And so if you, if you reject that, you're not a practicing Catholic, at least in belief. So I think that's. That's important. So. [00:42:14] Okay, a couple more comments. Drew says yet. Eric, for several centuries, eucharistic miracles have happened. Why Unbelief has been with us since the Last Supper. FYI, your son was awesome. Oh, thank you. You get on. I'm glad I put you on. Just because you said my son was awesome. Now, as a dad, of course I'm going to put that on. [00:42:29] Obviously, it's never been a hundred percent but you can tell me I would not, I would not believe tried to claim 1850 for 1850, 50 or 6 whatever that percent of self Catholics believe real presence it's simple. It's. It's just, it's not possible. I think the modern phenomenon now the, the six when was going around stop being self identified flux. I mean that's, that's a big part of it. So okay, so let's go last comment here. The good fight Tony says the bishop who requires kneeling for communion would be going against USCCB nor receive standing. Yeah, I mean that's the problem. That's the problem. Tony, you're right. If you, if you try to implement some of these things of communion on the tongue ultra rails, receive, kneeling, add, orient them. Remember all those four things I said? None of them were talked about at Vatican ii. None of them are like a, a implementation of Vatican ii. But they all happened. If you just simply did those, implemented those and required those. I think you just see a huge bump again number of cats who believe in a real presence. You'd also see a huge fight on your hands internally because the boomers would go crazy and it would be, it would be ugly. I personally think it'd be worth it. I think it'd be worth it, but it would be ugly. Okay, I'm going to wrap it up there. Thanks everybody for joining live. I really appreciate it. Again, my book is out today, the Catholic Guide to Artificial Intelligence. I encourage you to buy it at my website ericsims.com or @sophia Institute Press's website or if you have to, you can buy it at the big, at the big bad Amazon. So okay everybody, until next time, God love you.

Other Episodes

Episode

January 28, 2022 • 00:52:23
Episode Cover

What is the Anglican Ordinariate? (Guest: Fr. David Palmer)

Fr. David Palmer, a priest of the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham, joins Crisis Point to discuss the Personal Ordinariate, also known...

Listen

Episode 0

October 01, 2026 • 01:51:07
Episode Cover

The Age of Algorithms, AI, and Aliens

We live in interesting times, with algorithms controlling our online behavior, machines taking over our thinking, and talk of alien visitations increasing. Kale Zelden...

Listen

Episode

October 22, 2021 • 00:57:09
Episode Cover

How Eastern Catholicism Can Help in Our Current Crisis, with Carl Olson

Eastern Catholicism is a little-known part of the Catholic Church, but it might hold the secret to helping the Church out of her current...

Listen